![]()
Fig. 1. Photograph of Palm Canyon, 16 November 2010
Flora of Palm, Andreas, Murray and Tahquitz Canyons below 3000 Feet Elevation, San Jacinto Mountains
![]()
Fig. 2. Photograph of Tahquitz Falls, 16 November 2010Table of Contents
![]()
Fig. 3. Photograph of Tahquitz Falls, 6 April 2011
Introduction The Indian Canyons west of Palm Springs have always been a magnet for botanists, as well as tourists. Samuel Parish collected the first voucher in 1881, in Andreas Canyon, of a rare hybrid between Cheilanthes parryi and C. covillei, called C. X parishii in his honor. Since then, over 100 different botanists have collected a total of 1,156 vouchers from this area.
The main attraction of this area is that it is a desert area with water - lots of water. The steep eastern face of the San Jacinto Mountains, with a drop of over 10,500 feet in elevation in only 7.2 miles linear distance, from the 11,040 foot San Jacinto Peak to the 500 foot mouth of Tahquitz Canyon. There is essentially no place for this water to be used or absorbed by the plants or geology, and it all comes tumbling down to this area.
The resulting palm oases are a lure for desert denizens in the summer, offering shade as well as water. As can be seen from Fig. 1, Palm Canyon has a lot of palms.
But most interesting of all to botanists is that this is a fascinating transition between the vegetation of the coastal side of the mountains and the true desert to the east. It was almost mind-boggling to us to repeatedly come across coastal plants growing right next to desert plants.
This page is just a beginning of the flora of this area, since despite the large number of vouchers from this area, they all come from a very small portion of it. The two surveys we have done hardly even scratch the surface of the diversity here.
Yet even with the current incompleteness of the plant list here, this area is one of the more diverse areas for native plants in southern California, with 26% more species than is predicted from the best fit to the species - area relation for various places in southern California. This is a direct result of having abundant water, and by the mix of coastal, desert transition, and desert species.
There is much more work to be done on this flora, and much more fun to be had.
Unfortunately, the flora of this area also contains a brand-new-to-southern California, very-invasive annual grass that has taken over large areas on the open alluvial plain areas here, Stipa capensis, spear needlegrass (aka "cape needlegrass", "Mediterranean steppegrass", "twisted-awned speargrass", and "cape ricegrass"). This grass has even colonized areas along Tahquitz Creek. See Kate's 360° video panorama showing how extensively this grass has taken over here in places (click on the photo to begin the movie).
If you botanize here, make sure you remove all the seeds of this grass from your socks, shoes and pants before going elsewhere! Remember, the Coachella Valley is the same place that brought us the horrible scourge of Saharan Mustard, Brassica tournefortii. Don't help another invader spread!
Location The following map shows the location of the lower elevations of Palm, Andreas, Murray and Tahquitz Canyons, with georeferenced voucher locations marked with blue diamonds:
![]()
Fig. 4. Topographic map showing location of the lower elevations of Palm, Andreas, Murray and Tahquitz Canyons, with georeferenced voucher locations marked with blue diamonds.
Procedure For Compiling The Checklist The Checklist was compiled by the first author from online vouchers; from field work done on 16 November 2010 by the first two authors; and from field work done on 6 April 2011 by all the authors.
Voucher Records
The vouchers were obtained from five separate searches of the Consortium of California Herbaria on 18 November 2010:
- Georeferenced vouchers were searched between 33.75° and 33.82° N. latitude, and -116.52 and -116.58 E. longitude.
- Additional searches were made for all vouchers (not just georeferenced vouchers) that had the words Andreas Canyon, Palm Canyon, Murray Canyon or Tahquitz Palm in their locality field.
Duplicate vouchers were removed. The locality of each voucher was examined to rule out vouchers above 3000 feet elevation, vouchers that were out of this area, or vouchers from the urban area of Palm Springs.
Coordinates of the vouchers were then examined, and a few vouchers were removed that were outside this area.
The species list from the vouchers was then culled to remove species names that probably do not exist here, either because the location was not precise enough to be sure that the voucher was taken from the targeted area, or because the species determination on the voucher was unlikely to be correct. The rejected species are detailed below.
The online voucher determination of Gilia caruifolia was changed to G. stellata in the voucher list below, since that is the latest determination given on the voucher sheet. See Gilias of Lowermost Tahquitz Canyon.
Vouchers determined only to the species level were removed, and vouchers of a species and its subspecies were combined when there was only one plausible subspecies.
The above procedure resulted in a total of 349 taxa from 1,145 vouchers.
The dominant collectors, those with over 30 vouchers, are given in Table 1.
Table 1. Dominant Voucher Collectors
# Vouchers % of Total Name 175 15% F. W. Peirson 166 14% I. M. Johnston 120 10% N. R. Zabriskie, W. M. Zabriskie 79 7% W. L. Jepson (most with H. M. Hall) 60 5% N. C. Cooper 51 4% A. C. Sanders (most with G. K. Helmkamp) 43 4% P. A. Munz 40 3% F. M. Reed 31 3% Mary F. Spencer Field Surveys
Fig. 5. Topographic map showing locations of the first two field surveys. The two trails in red were surveyed in detail on 6 April 2011; Tahquitz Canyon is the northernmost trail, with the southernmost trail from the mouth of Andreas Canyon to the mouth of Murray Canyon. The trail in yellow was part of an additional cursory survey on 16 November 2010 in Palm Canyon proper. See Fig. 4 for a map of a larger area containing these surveys.
The field work on 16 November 2010 by Tom Chester and Robert Hepburn was very cursory, and done primarily when hiking, not botanizing. Taxa were noted mostly from memory several days later. Due to the time of year, most of the noted taxa were shrubs. Nonetheless, a total of 71 taxa were noted, including 21 taxa that are not present in the voucher list. The field work on 6 April 2011 was done by Tom Chester, Robert Hepburn, James Dillane, Kate Harper, Dave Stith, and Pam Pallette. A comprehensive survey was done from the southern end of the parking area at Andreas Canyon to the lowermost portion of Murray Canyon, followed by a more cursory survey of Tahquitz Canyon along the trail from the parking lot to the waterfall. Estimates of the plant abundances for the entire survey area were made only in the next several days after the trip, so the estimates are probably low for a number of species.
This survey found an amazing 171 taxa, including 37 taxa not present in the voucher list. Of those 37 taxa, 24 were species not seen in the 16 November 2010 survey, and were thus new additions to the Checklist.
The field work on 14 December 2017 was done by Keir Morse and Tom Chester, on our hike down the lower part of the Jo Pond and West Fork Trail, after surveying the trail for Malacothamnus densiflorus. This survey was done fairly hurriedly, since we were running out of time at the end of the day, and the lowermost part of the trail had to be skipped. That survey recorded 79 taxa, of which 23, 29% of the total, were not on the voucher list. Of those 23, nine had not been seen in any of our previous surveys, and so were new additions to the Checklist.
Total Checklist
The total checklist below contains 404 taxa. Of those, 200 were present only from vouchers; 145 were present both in our surveys and in vouchers; and 59 species were only found in our surveys. The dominance of taxa found only in vouchers fits expectations since we have surveyed only a miniscule portion of the area covered by vouchers. However, finding that 27% to 29% of the taxa in our surveys were not on the voucher list was unexpected, since it had seemed to us, from the number of vouchers, that this area had been heavily botanized in the past.
Important Caveats Please note the following important caveats about this preliminary Checklist:
- We have not looked at any of the vouchers yet, so we cannot vouch for their determinations. We have checked only the names of the taxa to make sure it was not unreasonable for them to occur here.
- The voucher taxon list is a very preliminary first draft, compiled quickly and without review by other knowledgeable botanists, and so well may contain bonehead errors.
- A few of the species from our surveys were not fully identified, usually due to lack of flowers. Those uncertain determinations are noted in the Checklist.
Plant Checklist See:
- Notes on the Scientific Names Used At This Site and
- Information about the links from the Scientific Name and Common Name.
The column with header Fam gives the first three letters of the Jepson Manual Second Edition Family.
An asterisk before the common name indicates a non-native species.
The column #Pls gives the minimum number of plants found in two areas. The first column, with header WF, gives the number of plants observed on a 14 December 2017 survey by Keir Morse and Tom Chester. The second column, with header MT, gives the number of plants found in the 6 April 2011 survey of Tahquitz Canyon from the parking lot to the waterfall, and in the southern end of the parking area at Andreas Canyon to the lowermost portion of Murray Canyon.
Many species are undoubtedly more abundant than are indicated by our minimum numbers, both due to our limitations in remembering how many plants of each species we saw for sure, and because surveys at other times of year might find more plants. The maximum number of plants estimated is 99.
A "~" in front of the number indicates that the taxon was not fully identified, usually due to lack of flowers, and hence our determination may not be correct. For Adiantum capillus-veneris, the uncertainty is because the plants are inaccessible on the rock cliffs of Tahquitz Waterfall, and were only seen from a distance.
Additional species seen in Tahquitz Canyon on 16 November 2010, or found by Robert Hepburn afterward, are marked with a T in this column, with one species found at Murray Spring by Robert Hepburn marked with a M. Additional taxa noted on 16 November 2010 in Palm Canyon immediately above the Trading Post, and at the mouth of Andreas Canyon, that are not on the voucher checklist, are marked with an X in this column.
The third column (#V) gives the number of vouchers for this entire area for each taxon truncated at a maximum value of 9.
See also the list of rejected species given below.
Version for printing, without lines and other text on this page: html (11 pages) or pdf Clickbook booklet (3 double-sided pages). (See printing instructions for an explanation of these options)
Taxa Rejected From The Checklist Taxa Rejected As Probably Waifs
Acrachne racemosa, UCR71763&. The Jepson Manual says that this taxon is either extirpated, lacking vouchers, or not considered naturalized.
Gossypium armourianum, JEPS102920. This is a cotton species native to Baja California, collected in 1995 from Palm Springs, ca. 1.5 mi S of jct of East Palm Canyon and South Palm Canyon. Andy Sanders wrote that There was an old agricultural extension station along the west side of the main road (Palm Cyn. Dr.) up toward Palm Canyon/Hermit Bench. These cotton plants are likely escapees from that. The Jepson Manual treatment says this species only persists from plantings in California.
Taxa Rejected Due To Uncertain Locations
The taxon name is linked to the online voucher record.
The following three species are higher-elevation taxa, from collections made by Jepson on a trip from Vandeventer Flat to Palm Canyon and back, and were probably collected in Palm Canyon above 3000 feet elevation, or from a Peirson trip along the Gordon Trail from Andreas Canyon to Mt. San Jacinto:
- Ceanothus greggii var. perplexans, RSA77714.
- Eriogonum davidsonii, JEPS56704;
- Monardella nana ssp. arida, JEPS63359.
Taxa Rejected Due To Probably-Incorrect Determinations
Allium haematochiton, UCR133190. This voucher was collected at San Jacinto Mtns. canyon above Palm Springs, which is not near other populations of Allium haematochiton, which is a coastal taxon. Perhaps this is actually A. marvinii, or perhaps the voucher was taken at an elevation higher than 3000 feet.
Amsinckia spectabilis, UC306211. This voucher is actually the type specimen for A. divaricata. The correct synonymy for this species is probably A. tessellatta, or perhaps A. menziesii var. intermedia, since A. spectabilis is an immediate-coastal species.
Cirsium neomexicanum, UC61517. This voucher is almost surely not Cirsium neomexicanum, which is only found in the eastern desert mountains.
Yucca baccata, JEPS46498. This voucher was determined in 1901, and its determination has apparently not been revisited since then. It is almost surely not Yucca baccata, which is only found in the eastern desert mountains near the Colorado River. This is probably Y. schidigera.
Voucher data provided by the participants of the Consortium of California Herbaria (ucjeps.berkeley.edu/consortium/).
Go to:
Copyright © 2010-2017 by Tom Chester, Robert Hepburn, James Dillane, Kate Harper, Dave Stith, Keir Morse and Pam Pallette.
Permission is freely granted to reproduce any or all of this page as long as credit is given to us at this source:
http://tchester.org/sj/flora/lower_palm_canyon_area.html
Comments and feedback: Tom Chester
Last update: 16 December 2017