Flora of Borrego Palm Canyon
Introduction
Location
Procedure For Compiling The Checklist
Important Caveats
Checklist
Introduction Borrego Palm Canyon is the most famous and most visited area in Anza-Borrego Desert State Park. It was originally called just Palm Canyon, and was well named since it has the third largest collection of palms in California, after Palm Canyon and Murray Canyon in Palm Springs. Randall Henderson, editor and publisher of Desert Magazine, counted 778 palm trees in the winter of 1940. The Canyon was eventually renamed Borrego Palm Canyon to prevent confusion with Palm Canyon in Palm Springs.
The Canyon was the first piece of property in what was then called Borrego Palms Desert State Park, one of the first State Parks in 1933. The Park Headquarters was originally located at the mouth of the Canyon until around 1957. The 1.4 mile Nature Trail leading to the first palm grove was built in 1933 with hand tools by the first park rangers. The Alternate Trail was built in the late 1960s by the La Cima honor camp inmates, and was known as the La Cima trail briefly. (Source for the historical information: Anza-Borrego A to Z, Diana Lindsay, 2001.)
The Canyon is without question one of the most delightful and special places in Anza-Borrego Desert State Park for a number of reasons. Among them are:
- The Canyon has a year-round stream within a narrow canyon. Other streams have more water (Coyote Creek and the San Felipe River have twice as much on average), but none of them tumble down such a steep course in a narrow lengthy canyon.
- The Canyon is simply beautiful with its combination of Palm Oases, riparian habitat, desert vegetation, steep slopes that create plentiful shade, and exposed rock.
- An easy well-marked trail leads to a waterfall and the first Palm Grove.
- Bighorn sheep are frequently seen here.
- The Canyon is extensive. The Canyon's mouth is at an elevation of 800 feet, and its origin is the highest point in San Diego County, 6407 foot Hot Springs Mountain, 10 miles west-northwest of its mouth. The stream drains an area of 22 square miles.
- The Canyon probably has the highest floristic diversity of any area in the Borrego Desert, from the montane forest in its upper reaches to the desert vegetation at its mouth.
The Canyon also is one of the most reliable places to see flowers in the Borrego Desert. It gets more water than places to its east, due to "spillover rain" from the mountain crest to the west during conditions of orographic rain, which is the most frequent type of rain southern California gets in the winter. Borrego Palm Canyon can sometimes get up to an inch of rain from such storms, whereas locations five miles east get nothing.
February and March flowers also survive better here than points east, for reasons I can only speculate about. Even after long periods without rainfall, the annuals on the alluvial slopes away from the stream can look happy here while annuals to the east are dying. This may be due to a combination of increased shade here, resulting in less evaporation from the soil, along with higher humidity levels at night that might give plants extra water from condensation.
The increased shade is due to earlier sunsets from the higher terrain to the west, plus extensive shade within the canyon itself from its southern walls coupled with the low sun angle in the wintertime. Even places not shaded by the southern walls might benefit from lower maximum daytime temperatures due to nearby shade.
This checklist is a pretty good start at a flora of Borrego Palm Canyon for two reasons. First, many botanists have visited the Canyon over a period of decades and collected specimens. Although I haven't yet retrieved the online vouchers for all areas of the Borrego Desert, I'd be very surprised if any other area of the Borrego Desert had more vouchers than here.
Second, I have spent 15 days from 2003 to 2007 surveying the 3.1 mile Nature Trail / Alternate Trail loop. Seven of those days were in the glorious 2005 prime season that produced a number of new records for the Borrego Desert. On most of those trips I was accompanied by the coauthors of our Plant Guide to that trail. My co-workers and I have also surveyed the Alternate Wash once so far.
Thus the list below is probably the most complete for any area of the Borrego Desert. However, many areas of Borrego Palm Canyon have not yet been explored, so more species will be added to the list in the future.
This checklist is only a start at the flora of this Canyon, since many of the entries come from vouchers I haven't yet reviewed, and I haven't yet vouchered all of the new records I have found so that my determinations can be reviewed. This checklist can only be considered a decent flora after I finish both of those tasks. This checklist will be revised as I work on both of those tasks.
Location Borrego Palm Canyon is directly west of Borrego Springs:
Only the portion of the Canyon below an elevation of 3000 feet is included in the Flora presented here. The boundaries of this Flora are shown in red in the map below (BPC = Borrego Palm Canyon):
The 3000 feet elevation contour is the jagged line on the left. The straight red lines are the lower-elevation boundaries for this area. The divide on the north is with Henderson Canyon, and the divide on the south is with Hellhole Canyon. The eastern boundary is taken as Borrego Springs Road for now, although I may move that boundary west to the State Park Boundary in the future.
Nearly all of this area in the Canyon is very rugged and has not been explored botanically. The main area of previous study is along the stream and the trails, shown in detail in the next map:
The 1.4 mile long Nature Trail is shown in blue, with two parallel sections in its north-south middle section. The western section is the pre-2003 route; the eastern section is the post-2003 flood route; see details on the changes.
The 1.2 mile Alternate Trail is shown in green. My Plant Guide is to the loop going up the Nature Trail to the first Palm Grove, then retracing the Nature Trail to the junction with the Alternate Trail, and taking the Alternate Trail down.
The red lines near the parking shown the route surveyed on 6 February 2008 for a flora of the Alternate Wash.
Procedure For Compiling The Checklist The Checklist was compiled from online vouchers and from field work done by myself and coworkers.
The vouchers were obtained from combining several searches of the Consortium of California Herbaria with a search of the San Diego County Plant Atlas, on 7 February 2008.
The first search of the Consortium vouchers retrieved all vouchers bounded by latitudes 33.265 to 33.301° and longitudes of -116.478 and -116.375°. The search retrieved 245 vouchers.
A second search was for all vouchers with the words Borrego and Palm in their locality. (I realized later I should have also searched for Borego, the older spelling for Borrego; I'll do that in the future). That search retrieved 707 vouchers, many of which were in other areas or duplicated taxa found in the first search and were removed. Vouchers that said only Upper Palm Canyon were accepted for now, even though they may have been taken at elevations above 3000 feet. I will work in the future to make sure the final Checklist includes only taxa definitely found below 3000 feet.
The combination of the two searches yielded 384 vouchers of 196 taxa.
Unfortunately, there is no way to search the San Diego County Plant Atlas / San Diego Natural History Museum Herbaria on latitude and longitude, so I couldn't perform the same search for records in the Plant Atlas that have not yet appeared in the Consortium database. But, fortunately, grid cell F23 covers most of my targeted area with only a little extra coverage to the south in the Hellhole Canyon drainage. Grid cell F23 spans latitudes 33.254 to 33.298° and longitudes of -116.458 to -116.430°.
There were 17 additional species found in the Plant Atlas / SD Herbarium vouchers, and I have included them for now in the Flora below. When I get the actual detailed records from the Plant Atlas / SD Herbarium, I will review them and remove those not in the targeted area.
There are thus 213 total taxa vouchered from this Canyon in the Checklist below.
By coincidence, Wayne Armstrong, James Dillane and Michael Charters and I have found the same number of total taxa so far on the loop trail, 213, but our list is substantially different from the list of vouchered taxa. Note that not all of our observed taxa are 100% identified yet, since some were never observed in bloom. Those taxa with only 95% confident determinations are noted in the Checklist.
Of our 213 observed taxa, 119 taxa appear in the list of taxa vouchered from this area, leaving 94 taxa as so-far-unvouchered new records for this Canyon, at least in terms of online vouchers. Of those 94, 29 taxa are recorded in the 1985 Checklist of Vascular Plants of the Anza-Borrego Desert by Duffie Clemons as having been vouchered here or someplace else in Floristic Area #16. Thus at least 65 of those taxa remain to be vouchered.
The number of new records from our trail work is not known yet, since several local herbaria have not finished digitized their vouchers yet. Also, I have already vouchered some of the new taxa found by us, which are counted in the 119 total.
The survey of the Alternate Wash by Wayne Armstrong, Kate Shapiro, Bill Sullivan and myself yielded 57 taxa identified with high enough confidence to list in the following checklist, along with ten other taxa that could not yet be identified due to lack of flowers. Of the 57 taxa, three taxa were species not found on the loop trail, all of which had been vouchered here.
There are thus 216 total taxa that have been located precisely in the field.
The combination of the vouchers and field surveys was then processed to remove probable duplication, and to make the taxa consistent with the 1985 Checklist, by assigning subspecies and varieties to vouchers only determined to the species. The subspecies and varieties were always the nominative ones, which is probably what was meant anyway for the voucher determination, with the exception that the voucher of Artemisia ludoviciana was assigned to ssp. incompta.
The above procedure yielded the 305 taxa given in the checklist below.
Note added 21 January 2016: the flora has been updated from four subsequent surveys of Borrego Palm Canyon, but the above text has not yet been revised with that information.
Note added 5 December 2019. The flora has been updated from iNat observations. While doing so, I noticed a number of species, with Borrego Palm Canyon locations in iNat, that almost surely were not found in Borrego Palm Canyon. Further investigation showed that those species came from two observers that had erroneous locations for their observations. In one case, an observer had attempted to assign locations to his photos from memory, and was badly off in some cases. In the other case, the observer simply used a location in Borrego Palm Canyon "as the central location of the many we visited over a 4 day period", but without assigning an appropriate error radius for his location.
Excluding those species, iNat observations added 11 species to the flora.
Important Caveats Please note the following important caveats about this preliminary Checklist:
- I have not looked at any of the vouchers yet, so I cannot vouch for their determinations. I have checked only the names of the taxa to make sure it was not unreasonable for them to occur here.
- Some of the vouchers may be from higher elevations, and will not appear in later updates of this Checklist.
- Some taxa present in the checklist only from our observations have not been 100% identified yet, since they were never observed in bloom. Those taxa with at least a 95% confident determination are noted in the Checklist with a "~" before their common and scientific names.
Checklist for Borrego Palm Canyon See:
- Notes on the Scientific Names Used At This Site and
- Information about the order in which the species are presented, and the links from the Scientific Name and Common Name.
An asterisk before the common name indicates a non-native species.
The column #V gives the number of vouchers found in this area, as detailed above.
The column #iN gives the number of iNaturalist observations found in this area, up to a maximum of 99.
The column #Pls gives the minimum number of plants observed in the sum of all field surveys, up to a maximum number of 99. An "x" in this column indicates a species for which no abundance estimate has been made. These are often "wash-down" species, that are present only when brought down from higher elevation by a flash flood; monsoonal species, present only in years with good summer rains; or found in the upper canyon that we rarely visit. When we next see them, we'll estimate their abundances.
Version for printing, without lines and other text on this page: html (8 pages) or pdf Clickbook booklet (2 double-sided pages). (See printing instructions for an explanation of these options)
Go to:
Copyright © 2008-2019 by Tom Chester
Permission is freely granted to reproduce any or all of this page as long as credit is given to me at this source:
http://tchester.org/sd/plants/floras/borrego_palm_canyon.html
Comments and feedback: Tom Chester
Last update: 5 December 2019 (Equisetum species updated 23 March 2023)